Graphic provided by the Providence Student Union.
By Kim Kalunian, WPRO News
More than half of the 50 adults that took an abridged portion of the math NECAP Saturday scored “substantially below proficient” according to the Providence Student Union.
The PSU released the results of their “Take the Test” event, which aimed to show that the NECAP is not a good indicator of future success. Under new graduation requirements, students would need to be at least “partially proficient” in the areas of math and English on their New England Common Assessment Program, or NECAP, exams.
According to preliminary results, upwards of 4,000 Rhode Island students would be in danger of not graduating.
“My eyes have been opened,” said test-taker adn State Rep. Teresa Tanzi (D-Narragansett) in a statement. “As one of the many capable and relatively accomplished participants who scored ‘substantially below proficient’ on this exercise, I do believe this points to a problem with our state’s new diploma system.”
“This is a fundamental misuse of this measurement tool,” said Tom Sgouros, a policy analyst in a statement. “The original goal of NECAP was to evaluate schools, and, to some extent, students within the schools. In order to make a reliable ranking among schools, you need to ensure that the differences between one school and another are statistically significant.”
State Education Commissioner Deborah Gist told WPRO Tuesday that she believes”it’s a positive thing that we’re focusing on the issue” but it’s not helpful to turn the conversation on the test itself and not on what the test is measuring.”
She initially felt the test, which she called a “publicity stunt” was a”clever project,” but the adults reactions to the questions were “unproductive” and sent an “untrue” message. Gist said if the adults had prepared for the exam, she’s sure they would have done well.
“Most people realize that educated adults can’t sit down and without any preparation be expected to do well,” she said.
She said a series of Tweets sent to her by high school students over the weekend demonstrated anger and fear about the test, which raised her concerns.
“We send a message to the students that the test is too hard or the test doesn’t matter, and neither of those are true,” she said.
Here is a full list of “Take the Test” participants:
Gregg Amore – State Representative (East Providence)
Luis Aponte – Providence City Council member
Dr. Wendy Becker – Professor, Rhode Island College
David Bennett – State Representative (Warwick)
Deborah Brayton – Former chief of staff, Mayor Cicilline and Senator Chafee
Steven Brown – Executive Director, RI ACLU
Maria Cimini – State Representative (Providence)
Abel Collins – Program Director, Sierra Club
Umberto Crenca – Artistic Director, AS220
Gonzalo Cuervo – Deputy Chief of Staff, City of Providence
Dr. Jorge Elorza – Providence Housing Court Judge
Gayle Goldin – State Senator (Providence)
Frank Ferri – State Representative (Warwick)
Ken Fish – Former Director of Middle and High School Reform, RIDE
David Fisher – Reporter, ecoRI
Art Handy – State Representative (Cranston)
Alan Harlam – Director of Social Entrepreneurship, Brown University
David Heckman – Attorney
Thomas Hoffman – Education Technical Consultant
Kevin Jackson – Psychologist, Providence City Council member
Matthew Jerzyk – Deputy City Solicitor, City of Providence
David Karoff – Development Consultant; former VP of Grantmaking, RI Foundation
Brian Lalli – Former Providence School Board member
Jeff Levy – Attorney
Alex Lucini – Teacher, Providence Teachers Union Executive Board
Simon Moore – Executive Director, College Visions
Alex Morash – President, Young Democrats of Rhode Island
Barbara Morin – Environmental Scientist
Anne Mulready – Attorney
Laura Pisaturo – Attorney
Bryan Principe – Providence City Council member
Shery Principe – Human resources delivery consultant
Bill Rappleye – Reporter, NBC10
Rick Richards – Retired employee in RIDE’s Office of Testing
Adam Satchell – State Senator (West Warwick)
Tom Sgouros – Engineer and Policy Analyst
Carla Shalaby – Director of Elementary Education, Wellesley College
Frank Shea – Executive Director, Olneyville Housing Corporation
Earl N. Smith III – Assistant Dean, University of Rhode Island
Susan Smulyan – Professor, Brown University
Dulari Tahbilder – Executive Director, Breakthrough Providence
Teresa Tanzi – State Representative (Wakefield)
Jim Tull – Professor, Community College of Rhode Island and Providence College
Larry Valencia – State Representative (Charlestown, Exeter, Richmond)
Miriam Weizenbaum – Attorney
Cliff Wood – Providence Foundation; former Providence City Council member
Jennifer Wood – Attorney
Karina Wood – Director, RI Tobacco Control Network
Myrth York – Community leader, former Democratic gubernatorial nominee
Sam Zurier – Attorney, Providence City Council member